The Risk of Bankruptcy for Mercedes, BMW, and Volkswagen: What It Means for Investors

The Risk of Bankruptcy for Mercedes, BMW, and Volkswagen: What It Means for Investors

Germany’s automotive industry is facing significant challenges. Pressured by rising competition in China, declining demand in Europe, and possible import tariffs in the U.S., German auto giants Mercedes-Benz, BMW, and Volkswagen are encountering major financial risks. Some analysts warn of potential bankruptcy, raising questions among investors: how far could these problems go, and is it wise to invest in these companies now?

Financial Difficulties and Declining Profits

Recent financial reports from German automakers show a worrying decline in performance. Specifically:

• Mercedes-Benz reported a 64% drop in profits to €1.2 billion, with profitability plummeting from 12.4% to 4.7%—its lowest level since the pandemic.
• BMW saw profits decline from €4.352 billion in the third quarter of 2023 to €1.7 billion, signaling significant challenges for a company once considered financially resilient.
• Volkswagen is even considering closing three plants in Germany, a first in its history, due to internal pressures.

These negative results suggest that German automakers are struggling to cope with external challenges, including the competitive threat from Chinese electric vehicle manufacturers and an economic slowdown in Europe.

Major Risks Facing German Automakers

1. U.S. Import Tariffs: Donald Trump has proposed raising import tariffs on vehicles as a measure to protect the U.S. auto industry. If tariffs increase (potentially from 10% to 200%), German automakers, who rely on the U.S. as a key export market, could lose significant revenue.

2. Declining Demand in Europe: The European automotive market is facing a decrease in demand amid high inflation, economic difficulties, and support for local producers, which weakens the appeal of German brands and threatens their market share.

3. Intensified Competition in China: The Chinese market, where German brands have traditionally held strong positions, is under intense pressure from local EV manufacturers like BYD and Nio, who are rapidly gaining market share.

4. Environmental Regulations and the Shift to EVs: Stringent environmental standards and the transition to electric vehicles demand extensive investment. This technological shift adds financial strain for traditional automakers, who must overhaul their production processes.

Government Support: Hope or Necessity?

Germany’s automotive sector is strategically important, employing around 835,000 people. A major downturn in this sector could lead to widespread unemployment, significantly impacting the economy. However, given the pressures on other sectors, such as chemicals and engineering, the government’s ability to provide support is limited. Germany may need to reassess its economic and industrial policies to preserve its key industries.

Possible Scenarios for Investors

1. Scenario of Government Intervention: Should the government extend substantial subsidies and benefits to automakers, companies like Mercedes, BMW, and Volkswagen may navigate through the crisis. However, this scenario would entail significant government spending and may not ensure long-term profitability.

2. Consolidation and Downsizing: If companies are forced to close plants and cut costs, it could improve short-term performance but may weaken their market position over time.

3. Restructuring and a Shift to EVs: To meet environmental standards and maintain competitiveness, automakers may accelerate their transition to electric vehicles. This will require investment but could attract “green” investors and funds focused on sustainability.

Should You Invest?

German automakers represent both a high-risk and potentially high-reward investment at this time. On the one hand, the current drop in BMW, Mercedes-Benz, and Volkswagen share prices may offer a buying opportunity. On the other hand, substantial risks remain, particularly related to global trade issues, competition in China, and European market pressures.

Expert Opinion: If you are prepared for the risks and willing to invest long-term, these companies could offer interesting opportunities, given their market-leading positions and the potential for government support. However, short-term investments may be less appealing in the current volatile environment.

Germany’s auto industry stands at a crossroads, and the coming years will reveal whether it can overcome these challenges and adapt to new market realities.

Sergey Tereshkin, founder and CEO of OPEN OIL MARKET, the first independent marketplace for petroleum products and raw materials in Russia, shared his views:
“Currently, we’re preparing for our own pre-IPO round, with an IPO scheduled for 2027 on the Moscow Exchange. I’m pleased to see that such financial instruments are gaining momentum in Russia, benefiting the country’s financial ecosystem as a whole.”